Wenjen, Mia. We Sing from the Heart: How the Slants® Took Their Fight for Free Speech to the Supreme Court. Victor Bizar Gómez, Illus. Red Comet, 11/2024. 48pp. Biography. Trade $19.99. 978-1-63-655087-9. GRADES 4–6. HIGH ADDITIONAL.
Stories matter, but it also matters who tells the story, especially in the case of stereotype busting. When Simon Tam realized his childhood dream of becoming a rock star in 2006, he turned a racist slur into a point of pride, naming his all-Asian American band The Slants. But time after time, his effort to protect his band’s name with a copyright was rejected, prompting him to confront a systemic double standard and take his fight for self-definition all the way to the Supreme Court. Dynamic, graphically strong illustrations in tans, purples, and teals pack a punch. Matte paper and a mix of printmaking, colored pencil, and ink wash add up to a sophisticated whole. Direct quotes or song lyrics are included on every page. Some overly broad language, pat phrases, and incomplete explanation blunt the impact of the powerful story and compelling specifics. The importance of the verdict and the paucity of Asian American biographies argue for inclusion in library collections. Back matter includes thumbnail descriptions of other important Asian American discrimination cases, sources, and brief notes from the author and subject.
Melissa McAvoy—Retired