Metcalf, Lindsay H. Tomatoes on Trial: The Fruit v. Vegetable Showdown. Edwin Fotheringham, Illus. Calkins Creek, 08/2025. [32]pp. Nonfiction. Trade $18.99. 978-1-6626-8053-3. GRADES 2–5. HIGH ADDITIONAL.
In 1886, John Nix imported tomatoes from Bermuda and was charged a tariff because they were classified as vegetables, so Nix sued the government, explaining that tomatoes are fruits. This lively informational picture book uses puns and wordplay and could be the basis for a fun unit on the justice system, debating, tariffs and taxes, or fruits and vegetables. The political cartoon style of illustrations uses ink and watercolor wash, depicting the era well. Although this subject is unusual and limited in scope, the book is thought-provoking and well done. Detailed backmatter includes tips on debating, a glossary, facts on fruits and vegetables, source notes, and more on the key characteristics of the lawsuit.
Penny Peck—San José State University iSchool