Smith, Linda Joan. Peach Thief, The. Candlewick, 03/2025. 374pp. Fiction. Trade $19.99. 978-1-5362-3778-8. GRADES 5–8. HIGH ADDITIONAL.
In this impeccably researched, sensory-rich, and well-paced historical novel, it’s 1850s England, where almost-teen workhouse-orphan-turned-street-urchin Scilla has landed in a position as an apprentice at the expansive kitchen garden of a wealthy Earl. Taken in when discovered stealing in the garden and mistaken for a boy by the head gardener, she assumes the identity of Seth Brown, first scrubbing pots to pay her debt, and then training in earnest in the skills of cutting-edge, 19th-century produce gardening. Surrounded by fellow apprentices and workers, including oh-so-charming head apprentice Phin for whom she’s quickly developing feelings, she grapples with emotional turmoil. Themes such as class inequity, sexism, and colonialism run throughout. The cover skews younger and more innocent than its contents, which include roguish teen philandering and romantic turmoil. A rare historical title not set in war or conflict, readers may wish to yell in frustration at Scilla at times, but her actions ring true, and Smith ultimately delivers what feels like a wholly original, satisfying read.
Riva Pollard—Sausalito Public Library